Successor Development

The 5 Most Common Successor Development Mistakes

Most business owners know that a well-groomed successor should have at a working knowledge of operations, sales and marketing, customer service, administration, and finance. But this knowledge, although necessary, is not sufficient if a successor is to effectively lead a company into the future. In addition to having a firm grasp of the mechanics of the business, a successor must become an effective leader, think strategically and have good judgment, have vision, and adopt an owner’s mindset.

Mistake #1: Not Developing Effective Leadership Skills
The effectiveness of a person’s leadership is determined by how they are viewed by the people they lead. A leader who is not respected or trusted can’t be very effective. In contrast, a leader who people trust and respect will always get better results.

People decide how much they trust and respect a leader based on how that leader acts and how they interact with others. When a leader demonstrates that they do what they say they’re going to do (acts with integrity) and demonstrates that they are the kind of person they claim to be (acts in integrity), people learn they can trust him or her.

When a leader interacts with people in a manner that shows they respect and value them, the leader will earn the respect of those around him or her. Leaders accomplish this by treating people like people (rather than like things) and by treating adults like adults (rather than like children).

Mistake #2: Lack of Strategic Thinking
The ability to think strategically is essential for a leader guiding an organization. Without an understanding of what a strategy is and how to develop one, leaders will often focus on goals and tactics. In the absence of a true strategy, these goals and tactics are often misguided and usually result in new challenges.

A goal is not a strategy. It’s just a metric to measure progress in the execution of a strategy. Plus, it has no emotional or inspirational component. Tactics are not strategies either. Tactics are the means by which a strategic initiative can be achieved. Tactics – like goals – also have no emotion or energy behind them. They are simply the mechanics of how things will get done.

A good strategy (in contrast to platitudes, goals or tactics) addresses a problem or takes advantage of an opportunity and provides direction for the company. Additionally, a good strategy inspires people to achieve it. By developing a true strategy, excellent results can be achieved, and the desired financial goals realized.

But an effective strategy also needs buy-in from the team. Without buy-in, a leader simply gets compliance, and compliance is not the same as commitment.

Mistake #3: Lack of Vision
For a leader to guide a company, it is essential to develop a vision for the future of the organization. A vision imagines a future which is better, different, and/or larger than the current state. Without vision, a leader will simply continue to execute the existing business model, often getting left behind as the economy shifts, customer/client preferences change, and competitors adapt.

The ability to develop vision can’t be learned from a book. It arises from within and it requires a leader to have passion and purpose for what they do. A passionless leader can only develop goals – which are uninspiring by their nature. If a leader wants to engage his or her organization, he or she must create a future that inspires people.

Mistake #4: Not Developing Good Judgment
A successor needs to develop sound judgment and become business savvy in order to make good decisions. Good judgment comes from our ability to recognize when our emotions and biases cloud our decision-making. When we allow emotions to cloud our judgment, we make decisions that are misguided. Having sound judgment – unbiased by emotions – allows an owner to make good business decisions.

Business savvy is developed by thinking broadly about all aspects of the business, by being aware of what’s going on within the company, within the economy, with customers, and with the competition. (It also helps to develop an understanding of human nature.)

Mistake #5: Not Developing an Owner’s Mindset
Up until a successor takes over as an owner, they have typically only ever been an employee. There are several differences between the way an employee thinks and the way an owner thinks, and if this shift doesn’t take place, problems will arise.

Employees tend to think narrowly. They usually focus on the task at hand and/or on their specific domain of responsibility (operations, finance, engineering, etc.). In contrast, an owner needs to consider the bigger picture and how his or her decisions impact each aspect of the business.

Employees tend to think short-term. Their focus tends to be on current matters, current revenues, current expenses, and current profits. On the other hand, an owner needs to consider both the short-term and the long-term success of the business.

Employees tend to focus on doing good work while at work but generally don’t take their work home with them. On the other hand, owners learn that the business becomes their lives, and they think about it all the time.

And finally, employees know that if they make poor decisions, the business doesn’t do well, they become dissatisfied, or they lose their job, they can always find a new job elsewhere. Owners understand that failure is not an option. Generally, there is no “Plan B.” They understand that the business is their only future, and this understanding colors their decisions and actions.

One Final Issue…
There’s one more issue that needs to be considered:
It’s nearly impossible for an owner to effectively develop their own successor!

Here’s why:

Interpersonal Dynamics – In order for meaningful improvement to occur, open and honest conversations with the successor must take place. But it’s virtually impossible for a successor to be completely open, honest, and vulnerable when those conversations are with the owner.

Blind Spots – Regardless of the number of years of experience we have, our level of intelligence, and the amount of education we’ve had, we all have blind spots. We can’t see what we’re missing. Owners have blind spots.

Objectivity – Virtually everyone around a successor has an agenda – their co-workers, their spouse and especially the owner. They either want things to change or they want things to stay the same. In order for a successor to hone their thinking and judgment, they need an unbiased sounding board. An owner can’t be unbiased.

Time Constraints – There’s a reason it’s called successor development and not successor training. The growth that needs to occur happens over time. It won’t take place simply by attending a workshop or reading a book. And most owners simply don’t have the time.

Skill Set – Successful owners are expert at the business of their business, but the skills that got them where they are aren’t the same skills required to effectively coach and mentor a successor.

It’s critical for a successor to be properly developed so that the business thrives after the owner leaves and all purchase payments get paid. The risk of handing your company over to a poorly prepared successor is too great to leave their development incomplete.

Contributed by Michael Beck

5 Strategies for Effective Successor Development

If you’re planning on selling your business to a successor (family or key executive), developing them as thoroughly as possible is essential. Not investing the time to properly develop them can lead to retirement delays, frustrations, missed payments or worse (like having to come out of retirement and salvage things).

After working with leaders for the last 20 years, we’ve determined that these are the five smartest things you can do – above and beyond teaching them “the mechanics” of your business – to maximize the likelihood of success.

1. Get an Objective Assessment
Let’s face it, we all have blind spots. And our blind spots cause us to miss things – especially when it comes to successors because we’re too close and have a lot riding on their success.

In addition, although you no doubt have many years of experience, your opinion is only part of the equation. It’s critical to find out how others view him or her, since they’ll be the ones who will either follow the successor’s lead or will choose not to trust and respect them.

The smartest way to evaluate a successor is by conducting a 360° assessment. This assessment solicits feedback from people all around them (you, peers, direct reports, etc.). The report generated by an objective 360°assessment will highlight their strengths and their weaknesses, which will provide you with guidance on how to further develop them to be more effective.

2. Have Regular Developmental Discussions
Successors can’t be trained. They must be developed over time. In other words, if successors could be trained, they could simply read some books and attend a workshop or two and become a better leader and an owner. It doesn’t work like that. For someone to become more effective as a leader and owner, he or she must break old habits and form new ones. They need to improve their interpersonal skills, learn to think strategically, and become effective at influencing others. In addition, they have their own blind spots and can’t see what they’re missing nor can they see where they’ve gone wrong.

That’s why, for successor development to be effective, it’s important to have developmental discussions once a week or at least twice a month. During these discussions you should talk about things that happened since your last meeting with them and suggest ways they could have handled things differently or more effectively. It’s an ongoing process and usually takes about 6-12 months to get the results you want.

3. Help Them to Think More Strategically
I’ve seen it over and over again. Leaders looking to increase profits develop a strategy to get better results. Except the so-called strategy they develop is not really a strategy at all. It’s just a goal. Or a tactic. Or sometimes it’s simply a platitude – a nice-sounding, but meaningless statement.

Regardless of whether they developed a goal, a tactic or a platitude, the results are always the same. The so-called “strategy” is never realized. No amount of encouragement, accountability or table pounding will lead to achieving the desired results. Only a true strategy stands a chance of achieving significant results.

In order to help a successor think more strategically, two things must happen. First, they need to understand the distinctions between strategies, tactics, goals, and platitudes.

A good strategy addresses a problem or an opportunity. Help your successor learn the differences between strategies and tactics.

And then they need to learn to differentiate between problems and symptoms. A strategy developed to address a symptom almost always produces weak results and always causes new issues to arise, thereby compounding the situation. The key, therefore, is to teach your successor how to uncover the problem or problems causing the symptoms.

4. Help Them to Be More Persuasive/Influential
Mastering the ability to influence others is critical to the success and effectiveness of a leader. A strategy, no matter how well thought out, will get mediocre results if there isn’t strong buy-in. A leader will always get compliance because of his or her authority. But compliance and commitment are two different things.

How do you influence people? How do you change their perspective, so you get buy-in? The most effective means of influencing others is by asking good questions and the use of analogies.

Asking good questions is an art. It took me many years to master it, with lots of practice and plenty of missed opportunities. Help your successor learn to ask questions that will change someone’s perspective. The right questions will give them insight into how the other person thinks and give your successor the needed insights to shift the person’s thinking.

The second tool for influencing people is through the use of analogies. Analogies are an excellent vehicle for bringing someone around to your way of seeing things. Help your successor see that using an analogy can help people “see” and “feel” the concept they’re talking about and does it in such a way as to keep them from becoming defensive.

5. Refine Their Decision-Making Abilities
As every owner know, it’s up to them to make the final decision on every significant issue. In order for your successor to make smart decisions, you need to groom him or her in several areas.

Often, decisions must be made without certainty about the future. Therefore, you need to help them improve their judgment and learn to balance risk and reward. They need to be savvy about business in general and understand financial statements. Since your successor has probably only ever been an employee (and never an owner), you need to help them think like an owner, see the big picture, and balance long-term and short-term needs. And finally, you need to help them learn the wisdom in getting outside perspective. It will help reveal blind spots and give them objective insights.

Properly developing a successor is important. The future of the business depends on it, the livelihood of your employees depends on it, and your retirement plans depend on it.

If you’d like help developing your successor, please contact us. It’s our specialty.

Contributed by Michael Beck

How to Choose a Successor

Selecting a successor to take over your business is serious business. The future of the company rides on it. The livelihood of the people employed depends on it. And the ability to make buyout payments to you relies on it.

In order effectively choose a successor, six aspects of a person need to be considered and evaluated:

Business Mechanics – their understanding of how the products and services get produced and delivered
Leadership Competence – their interpersonal skills, influence abilities, and a vision for the future
Strategic Thinking – their ability to distinguish between problems, symptoms, strategies and tactics
Sound Judgment – their ability to make good decisions and to choose an appropriate level of risk
Personality Traits – their drive, attitude, social skills and energy level
Cultural Fit – their alignment with the values and behaviors that matter to the company

Of course, understanding all this and ensuring a successor has all of these traits and competencies are two different things. Here are some guidelines to help evaluate a potential successor:

BUSINESS MECHANICS
Although understanding how the business works is important, it’s the easiest of the aspects to determine and/or develop. If they’ve worked for you for a while, you’ll have a pretty good idea of whether they understand the business. If they haven’t worked in the company, then have them spend time in each area of the business and see how well they do.

LEADERSHIP COMPETENCE
As an owner, a successor will (and should) spend much of their time leading rather than producing and delivering products and services. Therefore, leadership competence becomes critical for success. Fortunately, a 360 assessment will provide an objective picture of their leadership abilities and if needed, a professional executive coach can develop any areas needing improvement.

STRATEGIC THINKING
Reacting to a symptom instead of spending time understanding the underlying problem almost always leads to worse results. The best means of evaluating whether someone can think strategically is to allow them to develop strategies and present them to you. Not only will you be able to assess their abilities, but it will allow you to coach and mentor them if needed.

SOUND JUDGMENT
The only way to know if someone’s judgment is sound is to allow them to make decisions. Start with decisions that have a minimal impact on the on the business and/or can easily be corrected. As the decisions become more impactful, have them make their decisions in stages, checking in with you at each step so you can correct and mentor them before moving on to the next step.

PERSONALITY TRAITS
Before you evaluate a potential successor’s personality, you first need to decide whether the company needs an owner with the same personality as you or, at this point in the growth of the business, it requires a different type of individual. Once you’ve defined the type of personality needed, it should become fairly clear whether the individual has the needed traits. Remember, however, that unlike the other needed competencies, personality is innate and can’t be “developed”. Either they have the personality traits or they don’t.

CULTURAL FIT
Culture is defined by the values and behaviors demonstrated by the leadership of a company. If your successor doesn’t embody the culture you’ve established over the years, a different culture will emerge and the company will change. Additionally, if a leader professes to the importance of certain values but acts in a manner at odds with those values, it demonstrates a lack of integrity. Make sure your successor is living your company’s culture.

If you’d like our help evaluating and/or developing your successor, please contact us to discuss your situation.

Contributed by Michael Beck

Business Succession Insights Podcasts

Session 1: Business Transition Planning

Session 2: Business Transitions

Session 3: Succession Plan Applied

Contributed by Frank Dane

Developing Your Own Successor is Nearly Impossible

More and more business owners are finding that selling their company to an outsider is becoming increasingly difficult. As a result, they’re realizing that selling to a successor is the best way to receive the full value of their business when they retire. The plan will work beautifully as long as the business makes all the buyout payments. But the business’ ability to make those payments relies on the successor not screwing things up!

In order to maximize the likelihood that the successor does a good job and makes smart decisions, he or she must be developed effectively. In addition to learning about the business, they need to develop their leadership effectiveness, their strategic thinking, and their judgment. And therein lies the challenge…

It’s nearly impossible for an owner to effectively develop their own successor!

Here are the five issues that prevent an owner from properly developing their successor and what to do about it:

Interpersonal Dynamics
In order for meaningful improvement to take place, open, honest, challenging, and confidential conversations with the successor must take place. But it’s virtually impossible for a successor to be completely open, honest, and vulnerable when those conversations are with the person who will decide whether they will be taking over the company.

It’s unrealistic to expect a successor to acknowledge their shortcomings and fears in a conversation with the owner. It’s unrealistic to expect a successor to share their frustrations and dissatisfactions to that owner. And it’s unrealistic to for an owner to challenge a successor’s thinking or judgment and expect them to respond transparently and honestly.

The interpersonal dynamics between owner and successor make it nearly impossible for an owner to effectively develop his or her successor.

Blind Spots
Regardless of the number of years of experience we have, our level of intelligence, and the amount of education we’ve had, we all have blind spots. We can’t see what we’re missing. And because we have blind spots, it causes us to limit our thinking and the solutions we come up with.

In addition, when someone has spent a considerable amount of time in an industry and/or a company, they tend to develop “group think”. In other words, they tend to think about problems and seek solutions the same way others around them tend to think about and see those things. Group think limits the solutions we come up with.

Because getting past blind spots requires outside perspective, it makes it nearly impossible for an owner to effectively develop his or her successor.

Objectivity
Virtually everyone around a successor has an agenda – their co-workers, their spouse and especially the owner. They either want things to change or they want things to stay the same. They want the successor to act and make decisions in a way that gives them what they want. In order for a successor to hone their thinking and judgment, they need an unbiased sounding board.

Because getting objective perspective and having an unbiased sounding board are essential to improving a successor’s judgment and decision-making, it’s nearly impossible for an owner to effectively develop his or her successor.

Time Constraints
There’s a reason it’s called successor development and not successor training. The growth that needs to occur happens over time. It won’t take place simply by attending a workshop or reading a book. Development occurs as a successor deals with everyday issues and then gets outside perspective to shift how they lead, think, and interact.

Most owners simply don’t have the time needed to give a successor the attention required for effective development. Consequently, it’s nearly impossible for an owner to effectively develop his or her successor.

Skill Set
Let’s face it, successful business owners are pretty expert at the business of their business. They couldn’t have gotten where they are without developing that expertise. But in order for a successor to succeed in their development, they need to be coached and mentored. Mishandling this will produce mediocre results at best and may do more harm than good.

The truth is that the skills that got owners to where they are aren’t the same skills required to effectively coach and mentor a successor. By way of example, a seasoned professional executive coach goes through extensive training and years of practice to hone their coaching skills.

Because coaching and mentoring don’t come naturally to most owners, it’s nearly impossible for an owner to effectively develop his or her successor.

In summary, it’s critical for a successor to be properly developed so the business thrives after the owner leaves and all purchase payments get paid. In order to maximize the likelihood of that happening, it is essential to bring in outside expertise to help complete the development of a successor. The risk of handing your company over to a poorly prepared successor is too great to leave their development unfinished.

Contributed by Michael Beck